I’ve been using lore for a bit externally with lore desktop. Its OK, but definitely missing quality of life stuff, for example: you can’t see individual differences on past revisions, so your commit name, and description have to be decent.
It is strange that its not open source though. I am guessing epic games will try to charge for lore desktop once everything is more developed.
Tencent owned a 40% minority stake (edit: in 2012). Tim Sweeney still owns the majority stake and he’s the puppet master. His shoulders are plenty wide enough to take all the blame here, not that Tencent is a good corporate citizen but still, facts matter.
Also, Tencent’s share is down to apparently and approximately 28% percent. 40% was back in 2012.
Cheers, have a nice weekend one and all!
Sorry, bad wording. Did not try to say Tencent had fully acquired Epic.
Tencent used to be a bit controversial back then and got me to distrust Epic but, as you’ve said, they have lowered their presence in recent years and they never really did anything more than just capitalizing. This has also been the case with other companies like Riot, Supercell or Bluehole (you may know them because of Krafton: PUBG, Dave the Diver, Subnautica 2)
Tim Sweeney is in fact my biggest reason to dislike Epic. I have heard their engineers are good people, it’s always the CEOs.
I am still using Git for my small projects, because it is familiar and works well enough for solo work. Lore sounds promising for larger teams with lots of binary files, though, and the Godot addon makes it easier to try. I will watch how it develops before switching anything important over.
So what is the selling point? bin diff? Thats it?
The selling point is handling terabyte-scale projects. Unlike fossil, which also has delta-compression of binaries but requires the entire repository to fit in RAM. Also unlike git, which will turn your terabyte-scale project into a petabyte-scale repository because it does not do delta-compression of binaries.
I wouldnt put anything on there given thats its going to be fed back into Epics AI auto slop machine.
You are better off self hosting with something like Gitea, or Codeberg if you want something thats out there.
I am using Lore for private usage..
Running Lore on my own server and wrote my own GUI for the Desktop handling.
I would also skip Epics own Lore servers. But as a private backup running private.. it’s fine.
- Is allows for REALLY big binaries and even prebuilt Libraries - which don’t work with Git.
Still, and that’s something obvious, nothing compared to Git
Lore is not a codeforge, it is a VCS and can be ran locally or with your own server. Again, let’s please be thoughtful before criticizing something because of someone we don’t like. We are better than that.
In reality its still storing code changes, and those changes can be scrapped by AI, if Epic wanted to do so. Sure a locally hosted potentially removes that issue.
I’m not going to be ‘thoughtful’ to a company thats worth $22bn and openly admits that they are going all in on AI. I’m perfectly entitied to critise such a thing if I want to.
If people are worried about such thing then other self hosted alternatives exist. thats my opinion, The thread title is ‘Thoughts on Lore by Epic Games?’ is it not?
You are asking a question, and then are calling out an answer you don’t like.
Hey look, I am also on the anti-ai wagon, but you seem like my friend who will oppose anything because “screw big corps”.
You do realize using Lore does not report any profit to Epic, right? AI can scrape any data, Git or Lore, if they get access to it. It is not what is happening right now.
I should have clarified this is discussion about the tool, not the company. Alternatives are the whole reason why I made this post, because Lore seems, finally, like a promising alternative for game developers.
A tool is not inherently bad because of who made it. I reserve the right to assume you have not read the discussion, because I mention this about C#, which is an overlooked case by people, apparently.
In spite of the double standards that seem to plague this discussion, let’s talk about Steam, which I am almost certain you support.
- An estimated worth of $7 billion as of 2024
- Gaben’s net worth as of this month: $10 billion
- Valve’s posture on AI on their platform: they won’t police it further than what copyright laws allow for. “Clones have always existed, the market will regulate itself”.
- Steam applies 30% fees to all developers and reduced amount to really big games (e.g. Apex Legends). Epic, 12%.
- Gaben owns a collection of more than 9 super mega yachts.
Hey, I am not defending Epic, nor Steam. There’s no angel or devil, don’t act like there is.
So in other words, it’s not an issue.
If you use somebody else’s server to host your repository, the owner of that server can scrape your repository can scrape it. But the owner of that server is not Epic, because Epic does not provide Lore hosting. And if you put your repository on the internet without sufficient access controls, then anybody can scrape it, whether you’re using git or Lore or fossil or svn.
So, don’t do that.
I oppose AI in general when it comes to art and coding, yes. My view on companies in general is not what we are discussing here.
Epic ‘profit’ if they are scrapping users code for AI. There is more than just monetary ‘profit’ (although in the end thats what it all comes down to). Epic doesn’t need to provide access to code you might put on Lore into AI, that choice is firmly on them.
Thats like saying we should discuss Windows seperate from Microsoft, and 20 years ago, that would have been fine. Unfortunately Microsoft have made Windows an absolute dumpster fire of an OS, so there has to be some acknowledgment of the company that has built the tool and what they are currently doing in the space (in this case game development, Epic & AI).
C# is a programming language though, thats all , nothing more nothing less. I could argue that nobody should use it because Microsoft are activiely involved in genocide if I wanted to. But C# is 26 years old, way before MS decided to turn into what they have turned into. Thats a strawman, it bears no resemblence to what we are talking about here, which is a new tool, made now, by Epic.
BTW , I have no idea where you are getting that from. As it currently stands C# was not written in anyway by AI.
Steam might be profitting from AI, thats a concern for sure, however they explicitly state that if a project uses AI, it must state that. They have the same issue as Godot does with the forums, moderation is not easy.
And yes thats probably the correct response in general. Eventually people will get sick of it, and gaming will swing back to the other way again. Unfortunatlely we need to ride out the current AI culture to get back to the non AI culture.
Potentially, yes for now in its current version provided by Epic, not including UEFN.
I’m glad you’ve summarized yourself what Lore is. I don’t think we can advance this discussion further right now, sorry.
Damn, guess ill throw away my home datacenter for my pocket quintuple A studio now. Anyway yeah expected that someone would focus on compression.