It can be a good thing, but personnally, I’m quite upset about this announcement. I do not like to see an AI company invests into an open-source project like Godot or Blender, as I fear that, in a near future, this project becomes more AI oriented.
As far as I know, accepting a donation does not carry any requirements on Godot’s part whatsoever. Just like a Twitch streamer does not owe you anything if you give them 200 bucks. They’re not a shareholder.
The games in the video look spectacular, if you can reach such levels of quality inside godot they’ve got my attention, more people would be able to create better games… besides that… I’m going to prepare popcorns for the storm that it’s coming
Like plenty of sponsorships in the past it’ll be farmed for attention by some people and then promptly forgotten, people who actually understand sponsorships and have seen other sponsorships in the past not leading to any issues know better
I was about to prove my point about LLM tech being a good brute force leak detector:
To be clear: my stance is still that brute force expensive leak detection is the only positive outcome so far that impresses me somewhat… But the cost doesn’t really outweigh the benefits does it now?
Just to clarify, my comments were based on my impressions of the technical aspects from the videos I watched. As for the financial side of things, I’m glad Godot receives funding. At the same time, I hope tools capable of producing such impressive results become increasingly accessible, affordable, and, ideally, free.
and those who prefer not to use A.I. to start or assist their development will have a choice so everybody wins…
Just to quickly address these (somewhat similar) concerns: The Godot Foundation is not a publicly traded company, so you can not become a shareholder. It is clearly outlined what sponsors can and can not do on the page that was already linked by @athousandships:
Also to maybe give you some hope against your fear that Godot will become more AI oriented: the foundation has been sponsored by gambling and also NFT companies before, and yet Godot has not added any such features into the engine. Maybe the historical record can give you some ease in knowing that donations do not imply a reorganization of what Godot is. Sponsors do not decide what our priorities are, but they can help us in achieving them.
Who is condemning what? Godot has a policy on “AI” use on the official spaces, and for contributions, that’s all, regardless of what any individual contributor or maintainer might feel personally. Be they for or against “AI”
I don’t like that it gives them advertisement / visibility, but I think it’s fairly limited especially if we don’t give them attention. Ultimately it’s great if the money moves away from the AI market to cooler projects like Godot.
That’s the unfortunate thing with sponsorships, but the blog makes it a lot clearer when something is a sponsorship and not an official statement or position (though I do think the formatting is a bit unfortunate as it makes it look like “Manus is the world’s first general AI agent that turns ideas into finished work.” is a statement by the foundation and not a continuation of the statement by the sponsor, with the quote formatting making it look like the quote ends before then)
As far as I know not like they get any final say, I generally think Blender backlash was an over-reaction and Blender could of used extra funds.
Free things aren’t free, you want to keep Godot Free and Open Source you need funding. As long as they don’t get to dictate the direction of the engine and just have their name as marketing among sponsors, I say take the money and keep doing what you’re doing.
A Godot platformer template clone, Outrun clone, Mario Kart clone, Angry Birds clone, some generic casual golf clone. It’s the definition of slop. Wait, no Minecraft clone?